Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

False Positive | brightcove.com #710

Open
ClevyPasserby opened this issue Jan 16, 2025 · 9 comments
Open

False Positive | brightcove.com #710

ClevyPasserby opened this issue Jan 16, 2025 · 9 comments
Assignees

Comments

@ClevyPasserby
Copy link

ClevyPasserby commented Jan 16, 2025

What are the subjects of the false-positive (domains or URLS)?

  • brightcove.com
  • brightcove.net
  • players.brightcove.net
  • edge.api.brightcove.com

Why do you believe this is a false-positive?

I believe this is a false-positive because...
This affects edge.api.brightcove.com which is responsible for players.brightcove.net which plays wiley videos that cover math lessons.

How did you discover this false-positive(s)?

I discovered this false-positive by...
I was studying Trig on a school website and clicked on an outgoing link on a Trig lesson when the video was blocked, I checked the logs and found edge.api.brightcove.com being blocked.

Have you requested a review from other sources?

I have requested a review from...
BetterBlocklist
AdvancedBlocklist

Additional Information or Context

I have also noticed that...
Found it in domains1.list.
Also there is a previous issue similar to this.

@smed79
Copy link
Contributor

smed79 commented Jan 17, 2025

edge.api.brightcove.com and players.brightcove.net are whitelisted in domains.list

brightcove.map.fastly.net and media.brightcove.map.fastly.net are blocked in "Wiggum27 hosts"

@Wiggum127 FYI

brightcove.com & brightcove.net are blocked in "notrack-blocklists"
Already reported 9 months ago gitlab/quidsup/notrack-blocklists#57

@funilrys FYI.

@ClevyPasserby
Copy link
Author

ClevyPasserby commented Jan 17, 2025

I see that the domains are whitelisted, you see, I aggregate many blocklists and use python and golang scripts to filter out subdomains, dead domains and inactive domains. The subdomain script collects whole domains found and if it detects subdomains from the collected whole domains, then said subdomains are deleted. This in turn kind of made my curated aggregated whitelist (used to delete domains from my personal blacklist which are case sensitive) to be somewhat a bit ineffective as brightcove.com was detected.

Here's the logs from my domain checker script:

Files containing the domain:
brightcove.com is found in https%3A%2F%2Fhosts.ubuntu101.co.za%2Fdomains.list.txt at line 248058 which says brightcove.com
brightcove.com is found in https%3A%2F%2Fente.dev%2Fapi%2Fblocklist%2Ftracking.txt at line 15579 which says brightcove.com
brightcove.com is found in https%3A%2F%2Fraw.githubusercontent.com%2FLevi2288%2FAdvancedBlockList%2Fmain%2FLists%2Fprivacy.txt at line 964 which says brightcove.com

@WilliDieEnte
Copy link

+1
Are safe nowadays and don't contain pup / pua anymore

@Wiggum127
Copy link

Wiggum127 commented Jan 17, 2025

metrics.brightcove.com and goku.brightcove.com should remain blocked due to ad tracking.

will drop f1.media.brightcove.com as this no longer exists
will drop brightcove.map.fastly.net due to false positive
will drop media.brightcove.map.fastly.net due to false positive

Edit: to be clear, these are the updates I did to my hosts file. So these changes will be reflected in the ultimate hosts file if my list is the only one with the fastly.net entries.

@spirillen
Copy link
Contributor

Then let me ask you, as these data comes from external sources, which do you believe still are active, and which to be removed?

Search results

Lookup provided by My Privacy DNS

Hosts-Sources

External Hosts-Sources can be found here

ShadowWhispererTracking.csv:admin.brightcove.com
ShadowWhispererTracking.csv:beacon.playback.api.brightcove.com
ShadowWhispererTracking.csv:gallery-metrics.api.brightcove.com
ShadowWhispererTracking.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
ShadowWhispererTracking.csv:sadmin.brightcove.com
Ultimate.Hosts.Blacklist1.csv:brightcove.com
Ultimate.Hosts.Blacklist2.csv:goku.brightcove.com
Ultimate.Hosts.Blacklist2.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
adaway.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
anudeepND.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:accounts.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:ads.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:akamai.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:analytics.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:api.gslb.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:app.now.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:assets.map.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:astral.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:bcvid.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:blog.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove01-secure.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove01.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove04.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove04.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove05.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:cbn.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:cms.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:comeresa.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:comeresa.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:confluence.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:console.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:contentmarketingworld.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:corp.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:data.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:developer.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:distribution.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:docs.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:download.gallery.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:drupal.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:edge-elb.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:experiences.assets.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:feeds.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:files.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:forum.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:fps.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:gallery-metrics.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:gallery.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:get.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:go.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:goku.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:goku.gslb.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:help.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:hls.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:hls.cf.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:images.now.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:img.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:ingestion.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:internal.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:investor.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:jira.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:juni.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:learning-services-media.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:link.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:live.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:map.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:metrics.gclb.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:moderncustomerexperience.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:modernmarketingexperience.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:my.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:oauth.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:oembed.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:openapi.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:opensource.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:peoplecentral.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:play.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:players.api.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:playtokyo.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:playtokyo2018.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:prlic.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:pwc-outlook.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:register.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:sales.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:seoul.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:services.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:settings.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:signin.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:solutions.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:static.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:studio.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:support.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:supportportal.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:tempevpn.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:time.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:time.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:videocloud.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:videocollege.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:videomarketingacademy.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:videomarketingmentors.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:wvlic.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:www.brightcove.com
blocklistproject.csv:www.playtokyo.brightcove.com
hosts-file.ad_servers.csv:goku.brightcove.com
hosts-file.ad_servers.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
hostsFileOrg.csv:goku.brightcove.com
hostsFileOrg.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
migueldemouraAds-tracking.csv:metrics.brightcove.com
quidsUpMixed.csv:brightcove.com
someonewhocares.csv:metrics.brightcove.com

Sorted result

accounts.brightcove.com
admin.brightcove.com
ads.brightcove.com
akamai.o.brightcove.com
analytics.api.brightcove.com
api.brightcove.com
api.gslb.brightcove.com
app.now.brightcove.com
assets.map.brightcove.com
astral.brightcove.com
bcvid.brightcove.com
beacon.playback.api.brightcove.com
blog.brightcove.com
brightcove01.brightcove.com
brightcove01-secure.brightcove.com
brightcove04.brightcove.com
brightcove04.o.brightcove.com
brightcove05.brightcove.com
cbn.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
cms.api.brightcove.com
comeresa.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
comeresa.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
confluence.brightcove.com
console.brightcove.com
contentmarketingworld.brightcove.com
corp.brightcove.com
data.brightcove.com
developer.brightcove.com
distribution.brightcove.com
docs.brightcove.com
download.gallery.brightcove.com
drupal.brightcove.com
edge-elb.api.brightcove.com
experiences.assets.brightcove.com
feeds.brightcove.com
files.brightcove.com
forum.brightcove.com
fps.brightcove.com
gallery.brightcove.com
gallery-metrics.api.brightcove.com
get.brightcove.com
go.brightcove.com
goku.brightcove.com
goku.gslb.brightcove.com
help.brightcove.com
hls.ak.o.brightcove.com
hls.cf.brightcove.com
images.now.brightcove.com
img.brightcove.com
ingestion.api.brightcove.com
internal.api.brightcove.com
investor.brightcove.com
jira.brightcove.com
juni.brightcove.com
learning-services-media.brightcove.com
link.brightcove.com
live.brightcove.com
map.brightcove.com
metrics.brightcove.com
metrics.gclb.brightcove.com
moderncustomerexperience.brightcove.com
modernmarketingexperience.brightcove.com
my.brightcove.com
oauth.brightcove.com
oembed.brightcove.com
openapi.brightcove.com
opensource.brightcove.com
peoplecentral.brightcove.com
play.brightcove.com
players.api.brightcove.com
playtokyo2018.brightcove.com
playtokyo.brightcove.com
prlic.brightcove.com
pwc-outlook.brightcove.com
register.brightcove.com
sadmin.brightcove.com
sales.brightcove.com
seoul.brightcove.com
services.brightcove.com
settings.brightcove.com
signin.brightcove.com
solutions.brightcove.com
static.brightcove.com
studio.brightcove.com
support.brightcove.com
supportportal.brightcove.com
tempevpn.brightcove.com
time.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
time.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
videocloud.brightcove.com
videocollege.brightcove.com
videomarketingacademy.brightcove.com
videomarketingmentors.brightcove.com
wvlic.brightcove.com
www.brightcove.com
www.playtokyo.brightcove.com

EasyList

easyprivacy/easyprivacy_thirdparty.txt:||metrics.brightcove.com^

Matrix blacklist project

tracking/domains:admin.brightcove.com
tracking/domains:gallery-metrics.api.brightcove.com
tracking/domains:beacon.playback.api.brightcove.com
tracking/domains:metrics.brightcove.com
tracking/domains:sadmin.brightcove.com

Known Issues

@spirillen
Copy link
Contributor

Search results

Lookup provided by My Privacy DNS

Hosts-Sources

External Hosts-Sources can be found here

Ultimate.Hosts.Blacklist1.csv:brightcove.net
blocklistproject.csv:brightcove.net
quidsUpMixed.csv:brightcove.net

Sorted result

EasyList

easylist/easylist_specific_block.txt:||players.brightcove.net^$script,domain=military.com|pedestrian.tv

Matrix blacklist project

Matrix blacklist project, Filtered

Response Policy Zone - RPZ

Did not find any matching RPZ records

Known Issues

@ClevyPasserby
Copy link
Author

@spirillen Alrighty, gonna check on those domains. I mostly use zdns and dead-hosts-launcher to check the domains' status.

@ClevyPasserby
Copy link
Author

ClevyPasserby commented Jan 17, 2025

I. Alive domains

accounts.brightcove.com
gallery.brightcove.com
signin.brightcove.com
studio.brightcove.com
videocloud.brightcove.com
my.brightcove.com
solutions.brightcove.com
metrics.brightcove.com
metrics.gclb.brightcove.com
developer.brightcove.com
juni.brightcove.com
get.brightcove.com
api.brightcove.com
oembed.brightcove.com
analytics.api.brightcove.com
sales.brightcove.com
players.api.brightcove.com
openapi.brightcove.com
play.brightcove.com
peoplecentral.brightcove.com
www.brightcove.com
bcvid.brightcove.com
static.brightcove.com
help.brightcove.com
data.brightcove.com
files.brightcove.com
brightcove05.brightcove.com
support.brightcove.com
hls.ak.o.brightcove.com
brightcove01-secure.brightcove.com
edge-elb.api.brightcove.com
blog.brightcove.com
cbn.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
map.brightcove.com
experiences.assets.brightcove.com
time.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
img.brightcove.com
comeresa.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
brightcove04.o.brightcove.com
investor.brightcove.com
sadmin.brightcove.com
brightcove01.brightcove.com
admin.brightcove.com
brightcove04.brightcove.com
time.uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
uds.ak.o.brightcove.com
settings.brightcove.com
oauth.brightcove.com
link.brightcove.com
supportportal.brightcove.com
go.brightcove.com
assets.map.brightcove.com
download.gallery.brightcove.com
gallery-metrics.api.brightcove.com
images.now.brightcove.com
docs.brightcove.com
comeresa.pd.ak.o.brightcove.com
feeds.brightcove.com
beacon.playback.api.brightcove.com
ads.brightcove.com
ingestion.api.brightcove.com
cms.api.brightcove.com

II. Nxdomains:

distribution.brightcove.com
playtokyo.brightcove.com
goku.gslb.brightcove.com
api.gslb.brightcove.com
drupal.brightcove.com
videomarketingmentors.brightcove.com
services.brightcove.com
playtokyo2018.brightcove.com
astral.brightcove.com
pwc-outlook.brightcove.com
modernmarketingexperience.brightcove.com
www.playtokyo.brightcove.com
contentmarketingworld.brightcove.com
videocollege.brightcove.com
fps.brightcove.com
forum.brightcove.com
goku.brightcove.com
register.brightcove.com
opensource.brightcove.com
moderncustomerexperience.brightcove.com
wvlic.brightcove.com
tempevpn.brightcove.com
corp.brightcove.com
seoul.brightcove.com
prlic.brightcove.com
jira.brightcove.com
hls.cf.brightcove.com
akamai.o.brightcove.com
videomarketingacademy.brightcove.com
confluence.brightcove.com
learning-services-media.brightcove.com
console.brightcove.com
app.now.brightcove.com
internal.api.brightcove.com

III. Inactive domains:

# Generated by PyFunceble (v4.3.0a15.dev) / https://pyfunceble.github.io
# Date of generation: 2025-01-17T15:07:54.132043+00:00

Subject                                                                                              Status      Source     Expiration Date   Registrar                      HTTP Code  Checker       Tested At          
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- ---------- ----------------- ------------------------------ ---------- ------------- -------------------
live.brightcove.com                                                                                  INACTIVE    STDLOOKUP  Unknown 




@ClevyPasserby
Copy link
Author

@spirillen Here ya go.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
Development

No branches or pull requests

7 participants