You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Capture Gote's Lion with one of Sente's provided Birds (Falcon/Eagle). The exact way you capture does not matter.
2a. Upon doing this, you should see the counter-strike rule properly invoked when clicking Gote's provided Falcon or Eagle for the first time.
Move one of Gote's provided Birds (Falcon/Eagle) to the square immediately before the opposing Lion (so that it can be moved again), then click the moved piece again.
3a. Upon doing this, you should see that the counter-strike rule is not invoked, even though the game is still on the same turn.
What did you expect to happen? - After capturing a Lion on the last turn, capturing a Lion is not allowed during any part of the move.
What happened instead? - After capturing a Lion on the last turn, capturing a Lion with a Falcon or Eagle is allowed on the second part of a multi-move (but not for the first)
Explanation - My guess is that the developers simply forgot about the double moves of the Falcon and Eagle, and only added the counter-strike code for normal moves.
Fixing this bug shouldn't break any games, as Falcons and Eagles tend to appear toward the end of a game, and players will usually choose the most direct option to capturing a Lion. Furthermore, any player who makes the slightest effort to learn the rules before playing should know the Lion-trading rules.
Note - The precedent arising from Issue #830 is that non-Lion in the wording of the counter-strike rule means piece types, not move types. And since the non-Lion pieces include the Falcon and Eagle, this implies that the expected outcome should indeed happen, and the bug does need fixed.
Operating system and browser version - Any that supports Chu Shogi
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
amdewitt
changed the title
Chu Shogi counter-strike rule not involved on the second part of a multi-move move
Chu Shogi counter-strike rule not involved on the second part of a multi-move
Jul 3, 2024
Thank you very much for finding and reporting these issues. I will try to get the fix out today or tomorrow.
amdewitt
changed the title
Chu Shogi counter-strike rule not involved on the second part of a multi-move
Chu Shogi counter-strike rule not invoked on the second part of a multi-move
Jul 8, 2024
Exact URL where the bug happened - Example Position at:
https://lishogi.org/analysis/chushogi/lfcsgekgscfl/a1b1txot1b1a/mvrhdqn2rvm/ppppp1p1pppp/3i+D1+Hp4/12/12/4P+h1+dI3/PPPP1P1PPPPP/MVR2NQDHRVM/A1B1TOXT1B1A/LFCSGKEGSCFL%20b%20-%2017
Steps to reproduce the bug
2a. Upon doing this, you should see the counter-strike rule properly invoked when clicking Gote's provided Falcon or Eagle for the first time.
3a. Upon doing this, you should see that the counter-strike rule is not invoked, even though the game is still on the same turn.
What did you expect to happen? - After capturing a Lion on the last turn, capturing a Lion is not allowed during any part of the move.
What happened instead? - After capturing a Lion on the last turn, capturing a Lion with a Falcon or Eagle is allowed on the second part of a multi-move (but not for the first)
Explanation - My guess is that the developers simply forgot about the double moves of the Falcon and Eagle, and only added the counter-strike code for normal moves.
Fixing this bug shouldn't break any games, as Falcons and Eagles tend to appear toward the end of a game, and players will usually choose the most direct option to capturing a Lion. Furthermore, any player who makes the slightest effort to learn the rules before playing should know the Lion-trading rules.
Note - The precedent arising from Issue #830 is that non-Lion in the wording of the counter-strike rule means piece types, not move types. And since the non-Lion pieces include the Falcon and Eagle, this implies that the expected outcome should indeed happen, and the bug does need fixed.
Operating system and browser version - Any that supports Chu Shogi
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: