Specification of cis:if match="all" for field type

[PancakeFriday]

I was using the american-physics-society style for my thesis with Hayagriva and I noticed that webpages wouldn't render properly.

It has the following else-if clause:

<else-if type="post-weblog interview manuscript pamphlet personal_communication post post-weblog speech webpage">

Now the CSL 1.0.2 specification gives the following:

The cs:if and cs:else-if elements may carry the match attribute to control the testing logic, with allowed values:

    “all” - (default), element only tests “true” when all conditions test “true” for all given test values
    “any” - element tests “true” when any condition tests “true” for any given test value
    “none” - element only tests “true” when none of the conditions test “true” for any given test value

According to this, type would have to match all types. I can see how with the BibTeX specification this is not possible, however it's not specifically stated that match="all" still only matches one style. Is that the case? Using the online code editor seems to verify that theory.

Also, for all other conditionals, the american-physics-society.csl does have the match="any" attribute, which adds to the confusion.

[POBrien333]

So, the "all" we use for example when we test for a journal article that has no printed copy to then render the DOI. We'd test for "volume AND page" in such a case, not "volume ANY page" (the any is like an "or".

for the aps.csl that is just an error that it is missing and should be added. However, I see that despite that it not being in the style it's still working. Probably just because a given item can just have ONE item type and could never have 2 item types.

[adam3smith]

just to be clear (because I think POBrien lost a word somewhere), what's missing in the APS style is match="any"
There should never be a list of item types without match="any"

[POBrien333]

PR made.