diff --git a/src/test/regress/expected/columnar_insert.out b/src/test/regress/expected/columnar_insert.out
index 5ec0ed38365..a2831aa87a8 100644
--- a/src/test/regress/expected/columnar_insert.out
+++ b/src/test/regress/expected/columnar_insert.out
@@ -122,33 +122,54 @@ DROP TABLE test_logical_replication;
 -- test toast interactions
 --
 -- row table with data in different storage formats
-CREATE TABLE test_toast_row(plain TEXT, main TEXT, external TEXT, extended TEXT);
+CREATE TABLE test_toast_row(
+  plain TEXT,
+  main_pglz TEXT COMPRESSION pglz,
+  main_lz4 TEXT COMPRESSION lz4,
+  external TEXT,
+  extended_pglz TEXT COMPRESSION pglz,
+  extended_lz4 TEXT COMPRESSION lz4
+);
 ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN plain SET STORAGE plain; -- inline, uncompressed
-ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main_pglz SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed using pglz
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main_lz4 SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed using lz4
 ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN external SET STORAGE external; -- out-of-line, uncompressed
-ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended_pglz SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed using pglz
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended_lz4 SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed using lz4
 INSERT INTO test_toast_row VALUES(
-       repeat('w', 5000), repeat('x', 5000), repeat('y', 5000), repeat('z', 5000));
+  repeat('u', 5000), repeat('v', 5000), repeat('w', 5000),
+  repeat('x', 5000), repeat('y', 5000), repeat('z', 5000)
+);
 SELECT
-  pg_column_size(plain), pg_column_size(main),
-  pg_column_size(external), pg_column_size(extended)
+  pg_column_size(plain) AS plain,
+  pg_column_size(main_pglz) as main_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(main_lz4) as main_lz4,
+  pg_column_size(external) as external,
+  pg_column_size(extended_pglz) as extended_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(extended_lz4) as extended_lz4
 FROM test_toast_row;
- pg_column_size | pg_column_size | pg_column_size | pg_column_size
+ plain | main_pglz | main_lz4 | external | extended_pglz | extended_lz4
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------
-           5004 |             69 |           5000 |             65
+  5004 |        69 |       38 |     5000 |            65 |           34
 (1 row)
 
-CREATE TABLE test_toast_columnar(plain TEXT, main TEXT, external TEXT, extended TEXT)
+CREATE TABLE test_toast_columnar(plain TEXT, main_pglz TEXT, main_lz4 TEXT,
+                                 external TEXT, extended_pglz TEXT, extended_lz4 TEXT)
   USING columnar;
-INSERT INTO test_toast_columnar SELECT plain, main, external, extended
+INSERT INTO test_toast_columnar
+  SELECT plain, main_pglz, main_lz4, external, extended_pglz, extended_lz4
   FROM test_toast_row;
 SELECT
-  pg_column_size(plain), pg_column_size(main),
-  pg_column_size(external), pg_column_size(extended)
+  pg_column_size(plain) AS plain,
+  pg_column_size(main_pglz) as main_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(main_lz4) as main_lz4,
+  pg_column_size(external) as external,
+  pg_column_size(extended_pglz) as extended_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(extended_lz4) as extended_lz4
 FROM test_toast_columnar;
- pg_column_size | pg_column_size | pg_column_size | pg_column_size
+ plain | main_pglz | main_lz4 | external | extended_pglz | extended_lz4
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------
-           5004 |           5004 |           5004 |           5004
+  5004 |      5004 |     5004 |     5004 |          5004 |         5004
 (1 row)
 
 select
diff --git a/src/test/regress/sql/columnar_insert.sql b/src/test/regress/sql/columnar_insert.sql
index 3387f4a0aeb..5c2e042f96f 100644
--- a/src/test/regress/sql/columnar_insert.sql
+++ b/src/test/regress/sql/columnar_insert.sql
@@ -83,27 +83,50 @@ DROP TABLE test_logical_replication;
 --
 
 -- row table with data in different storage formats
-CREATE TABLE test_toast_row(plain TEXT, main TEXT, external TEXT, extended TEXT);
+CREATE TABLE test_toast_row(
+  plain TEXT,
+  main_pglz TEXT COMPRESSION pglz,
+  main_lz4 TEXT COMPRESSION lz4,
+  external TEXT,
+  extended_pglz TEXT COMPRESSION pglz,
+  extended_lz4 TEXT COMPRESSION lz4
+);
 ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN plain SET STORAGE plain; -- inline, uncompressed
-ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main_pglz SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed using pglz
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN main_lz4 SET STORAGE main; -- inline, compressed using lz4
 ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN external SET STORAGE external; -- out-of-line, uncompressed
-ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended_pglz SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed using pglz
+ALTER TABLE test_toast_row ALTER COLUMN extended_lz4 SET STORAGE extended; -- out-of-line, compressed using lz4
 
 INSERT INTO test_toast_row VALUES(
-       repeat('w', 5000), repeat('x', 5000), repeat('y', 5000), repeat('z', 5000));
+  repeat('u', 5000), repeat('v', 5000), repeat('w', 5000),
+  repeat('x', 5000), repeat('y', 5000), repeat('z', 5000)
+);
 
 SELECT
-  pg_column_size(plain), pg_column_size(main),
-  pg_column_size(external), pg_column_size(extended)
+  pg_column_size(plain) AS plain,
+  pg_column_size(main_pglz) as main_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(main_lz4) as main_lz4,
+  pg_column_size(external) as external,
+  pg_column_size(extended_pglz) as extended_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(extended_lz4) as extended_lz4
 FROM test_toast_row;
 
-CREATE TABLE test_toast_columnar(plain TEXT, main TEXT, external TEXT, extended TEXT)
+CREATE TABLE test_toast_columnar(plain TEXT, main_pglz TEXT, main_lz4 TEXT,
+                                 external TEXT, extended_pglz TEXT, extended_lz4 TEXT)
   USING columnar;
-INSERT INTO test_toast_columnar SELECT plain, main, external, extended
+
+INSERT INTO test_toast_columnar
+  SELECT plain, main_pglz, main_lz4, external, extended_pglz, extended_lz4
   FROM test_toast_row;
+
 SELECT
-  pg_column_size(plain), pg_column_size(main),
-  pg_column_size(external), pg_column_size(extended)
+  pg_column_size(plain) AS plain,
+  pg_column_size(main_pglz) as main_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(main_lz4) as main_lz4,
+  pg_column_size(external) as external,
+  pg_column_size(extended_pglz) as extended_pglz,
+  pg_column_size(extended_lz4) as extended_lz4
 FROM test_toast_columnar;
 
 select