"Target, at Most" "Every Week" not working

[nickyvanurk]

Pre-submission checklist

• [ x] I am submitting a bug report, not a feature request.
• [ x] I have searched for similar issues, but did not find any matches.

Description

Calendar and streaks not showing you breaking your habit.

Steps to reproduce

1. Create new habit with settings as in screenshot
2. Add new entries that are below target but accumulated during the week are more than the "target, at most" value
3. Calendar and streaks don't show you breaking your habit goal, it assumes all is well which is wrong because during the 3 weeks the total was 7 then 6 then 7.

System information

• Phone: huawai p smart z
• Phone Operating System: Android 10
• App version: 2.3.1

Screenshots

[KarthikeyanSathiyamoorthi]

I think the calendar view and the streaks bar are taking 4.0 as a daily target instead of a weekly one.
I added the same value as you (see my screenshots).

Did you run into the same issue?

[nickyvanurk]

What do you mean did I run into the same issue? You're describing the problem I've already described in my first post.

I've set the maximum to 4 per week but even with 7 or 6 per week the habit tracker doesn't recognize it as breaking my habit rule of 4 max per week. Which is wrong. So yes it does seem the target is always processed as a max per day value even though I specified it to be "every week".

[KyleSCraig]

I've done some work towards fixing this. Currently busy but also even for when I have time I realized I'm not confident in it getting merged because I went down a path that I feel is consistent with yes/no habits before I realized that measurable habits are done without rolling windows of time. So I think basically measurable habits aren't fully implemented but we need to make a big plan for how we implement them.

[nickyvanurk]

Wouldn't be too difficult I imagine. I would go with "every week" meaning Monday until Sunday (one vertical bar in the Calendar view) and not a rolling window of time or anything (e.g. if you start your habit on Wednesday, it's already the third day in the week, previous days are considered 0).

[MaheshAravindV]

Is someone working on this? If not, I can pick it up

[thomast87]

I ran into this very same issue today. Is somebody working on it maybe?