Skip to content

V2 : reTesselateCoplanarPolygons seems to have a problem #194

@FishOrBear

Description

@FishOrBear

ver:V2

Primitive triangle mesh
image

reTesselateCoplanarPolygons (draw line
image

reTesselateCoplanarPolygons (draw face
image

testcode:

console.log("test");
let geo = geom3.fromPoints([[[585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0], [585.9650675011303, 0, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 0, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 487.06177308554817, 0], [0, 487.06177308554817, 0], [0, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 953.0992486712241, 0], [585.9650675011303, 1200, 0], [569.7829030842556, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 953.0992486712241, 0]], [[41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0], [0, 1200, 0], [0, 1163.7793495535184, 0], [41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0]], [[580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0], [569.7829030842556, 1200, 0], [399.0792683898784, 1200, 0], [580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0]], [[89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0], [41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0], [0, 1163.7793495535184, 0], [0, 1111.133491795949, 0], [89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0]], [[513.8373819542935, 1099.3596856831782, 0], [399.0792683898784, 1200, 0], [363.21825136572335, 1200, 0], [513.8373819542935, 1099.3596856831782, 0]], [[212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0], [89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0], [0, 1111.133491795949, 0], [0, 683.1732572016322, 0], [212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0]], [[581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0], [580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0], [531.96799718878, 1083.4595391987045, 0], [581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0]], [[218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0], [212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0], [0, 683.1732572016322, 0], [0, 554.6549147914332, 0], [218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0]], [[493.78635656364474, 1112.7573297261627, 0], [363.21825136572335, 1200, 0], [316.8756808655663, 1200, 0], [493.78635656364474, 1112.7573297261627, 0]], [[49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0], [221.18866516331374, 993.9098336745839, 0], [218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0], [0, 554.6549147914332, 0], [0, 487.06177308554817, 0], [49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0], [581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0], [547.8681436727304, 1065.3288629296528, 0], [581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0]], [[49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0], [121.3387404549834, 487.06177308554817, 0], [222.00728710207946, 993.1470914635701, 0], [221.18866516331374, 993.9098336745839, 0], [49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[472.1581827354736, 1123.4231622457141, 0], [316.8756808655663, 1200, 0], [246.57062466362078, 1200, 0], [472.1581827354736, 1123.4231622457141, 0]], [[218.827738399571, 977.1627252339831, 0], [121.3387404549834, 487.06177308554817, 0], [186.70594798035887, 487.06177308554817, 0], [218.827738399571, 977.1627252339831, 0]], [[582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0], [581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0], [561.265848751198, 1045.2778985736759, 0], [582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0]], [[217.2505899620678, 953.0992486714372, 0], [186.70594798035887, 487.06177308554817, 0], [217.2505899620678, 487.06177308554817, 0], [217.2505899620678, 953.0992486714372, 0]], [[449.3229776573378, 1131.174688124625, 0], [246.57062466362078, 1200, 0], [103.31238340676235, 1200, 0], [449.3229776573378, 1131.174688124625, 0]], [[583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0], [582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0], [571.9316202354629, 1023.6497247457753, 0], [583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0]], [[41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0], [425.6712442587688, 1135.8792779683997, 0], [103.31238340676235, 1200, 0], [0, 1200, 0], [41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0]], [[584.3879190636148, 977.1627252339455, 0], [583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0], [579.6833292198446, 1000.8144586324776, 0], [584.3879190636148, 977.1627252339455, 0]], [[401.6077676964492, 1137.45648744104, 0], [41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0], [89.1085882342773, 1116.9740286796978, 0], [401.6077676964492, 1137.45648744104, 0]], [[299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0], [89.1085882342773, 1116.9740286796978, 0], [212.8304304392181, 1001.6975292294347, 0], [299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0]], [[313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0], [299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0], [255.34739172003987, 1065.3288629295075, 0], [313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0]], [[241.94980871197896, 1045.2778985736684, 0], [212.8304304392181, 1001.6975292294347, 0], [218.05679312426327, 996.827921854922, 0], [241.94980871197896, 1045.2778985736684, 0]], [[327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0], [313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0], [271.2475382041619, 1083.4595391987518, 0], [327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0]], [[231.28391515742027, 1023.6497247458037, 0], [218.05679312426327, 996.827921854922, 0], [221.18866516331377, 993.9098336745839, 0], [231.28391515742027, 1023.6497247458037, 0]], [[340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0], [327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0], [289.3782755088521, 1099.3596856831293, 0], [340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0]], [[223.53245031363113, 1000.814458632408, 0], [221.18866516331377, 993.9098336745839, 0], [222.00728710207954, 993.14709146357, 0], [223.53245031363113, 1000.814458632408, 0]], [[353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0], [340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0], [309.429178829119, 1112.7573297260667, 0], [353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0]], [[365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0], [353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0], [331.0573526576802, 1123.4231622458103, 0], [365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0]], [[377.54441320450195, 1135.879277968397, 0], [365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0], [353.89267980570315, 1131.1746881245763, 0], [377.54441320450195, 1135.879277968397, 0]]])
console.log(geo);
let ps = reTesselateCoplanarPolygons(geo.polygons)
console.log(ps.length);
console.log(JSON.stringify(ps));

Is this expected?

v0.7 testcode:

let d = [[[585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0], [585.9650675011303, 0, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 0, 0], [1287.9139404296875, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 654.0333333399891, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 487.06177308554817, 0], [0, 487.06177308554817, 0], [0, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 0, 0], [585.9650675011303, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[585.9650675011303, 953.0992486712241, 0], [585.9650675011303, 1200, 0], [569.7829030842556, 1200, 0], [585.9650675011303, 953.0992486712241, 0]], [[41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0], [0, 1200, 0], [0, 1163.7793495535184, 0], [41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0]], [[580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0], [569.7829030842556, 1200, 0], [399.0792683898784, 1200, 0], [580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0]], [[89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0], [41.815788313545774, 1161.038587749494, 0], [0, 1163.7793495535184, 0], [0, 1111.133491795949, 0], [89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0]], [[513.8373819542935, 1099.3596856831782, 0], [399.0792683898784, 1200, 0], [363.21825136572335, 1200, 0], [513.8373819542935, 1099.3596856831782, 0]], [[212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0], [89.10858823427716, 1116.974028679698, 0], [0, 1111.133491795949, 0], [0, 683.1732572016322, 0], [212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0]], [[581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0], [580.192984433049, 1041.1672975136432, 0], [531.96799718878, 1083.4595391987045, 0], [581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0]], [[218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0], [212.83043043921808, 1001.6975292294348, 0], [0, 683.1732572016322, 0], [0, 554.6549147914332, 0], [218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0]], [[493.78635656364474, 1112.7573297261627, 0], [363.21825136572335, 1200, 0], [316.8756808655663, 1200, 0], [493.78635656364474, 1112.7573297261627, 0]], [[49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0], [221.18866516331374, 993.9098336745839, 0], [218.0567931242633, 996.827921854922, 0], [0, 554.6549147914332, 0], [0, 487.06177308554817, 0], [49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0], [581.0924424726376, 1027.443739895384, 0], [547.8681436727304, 1065.3288629296528, 0], [581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0]], [[49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0], [121.3387404549834, 487.06177308554817, 0], [222.00728710207946, 993.1470914635701, 0], [221.18866516331374, 993.9098336745839, 0], [49.1383416291427, 487.06177308554817, 0]], [[472.1581827354736, 1123.4231622457141, 0], [316.8756808655663, 1200, 0], [246.57062466362078, 1200, 0], [472.1581827354736, 1123.4231622457141, 0]], [[218.827738399571, 977.1627252339831, 0], [121.3387404549834, 487.06177308554817, 0], [186.70594798035887, 487.06177308554817, 0], [218.827738399571, 977.1627252339831, 0]], [[582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0], [581.9527194048013, 1014.3179913595105, 0], [561.265848751198, 1045.2778985736759, 0], [582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0]], [[217.2505899620678, 953.0992486714372, 0], [186.70594798035887, 487.06177308554817, 0], [217.2505899620678, 487.06177308554817, 0], [217.2505899620678, 953.0992486714372, 0]], [[449.3229776573378, 1131.174688124625, 0], [246.57062466362078, 1200, 0], [103.31238340676235, 1200, 0], [449.3229776573378, 1131.174688124625, 0]], [[583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0], [582.7833584469377, 1001.6444454540801, 0], [571.9316202354629, 1023.6497247457753, 0], [583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0]], [[41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0], [425.6712442587688, 1135.8792779683997, 0], [103.31238340676235, 1200, 0], [0, 1200, 0], [41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0]], [[584.3879190636148, 977.1627252339455, 0], [583.5925177127425, 989.2986290648014, 0], [579.6833292198446, 1000.8144586324776, 0], [584.3879190636148, 977.1627252339455, 0]], [[401.6077676964492, 1137.45648744104, 0], [41.815788313545795, 1161.038587749494, 0], [89.1085882342773, 1116.9740286796978, 0], [401.6077676964492, 1137.45648744104, 0]], [[299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0], [89.1085882342773, 1116.9740286796978, 0], [212.8304304392181, 1001.6975292294347, 0], [299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0]], [[313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0], [299.0498522338729, 1130.7344273136287, 0], [255.34739172003987, 1065.3288629295075, 0], [313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0]], [[241.94980871197896, 1045.2778985736684, 0], [212.8304304392181, 1001.6975292294347, 0], [218.05679312426327, 996.827921854922, 0], [241.94980871197896, 1045.2778985736684, 0]], [[327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0], [313.539283885475, 1131.6841232033587, 0], [271.2475382041619, 1083.4595391987518, 0], [327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0]], [[231.28391515742027, 1023.6497247458037, 0], [218.05679312426327, 996.827921854922, 0], [221.18866516331377, 993.9098336745839, 0], [231.28391515742027, 1023.6497247458037, 0]], [[340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0], [327.26313294742744, 1132.5836397171047, 0], [289.3782755088521, 1099.3596856831293, 0], [340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0]], [[223.53245031363113, 1000.814458632408, 0], [221.18866516331377, 993.9098336745839, 0], [222.00728710207954, 993.14709146357, 0], [223.53245031363113, 1000.814458632408, 0]], [[353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0], [340.3887518543665, 1133.4439458095596, 0], [309.429178829119, 1112.7573297260667, 0], [353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0]], [[365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0], [353.06188489489995, 1134.2745941502255, 0], [331.0573526576802, 1123.4231622458103, 0], [365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0]], [[377.54441320450195, 1135.879277968397, 0], [365.40875752726663, 1135.0838580656036, 0], [353.89267980570315, 1131.1746881245763, 0], [377.54441320450195, 1135.879277968397, 0]]];

let polygons = d.map(pts =>
{
  let polyon = Polygon.createFromPoints(pts);
  return polyon
})
let dest = [];
reTesselateCoplanarPolygons(polygons, dest)
console.log(dest);
console.log(JSON.stringify(dest));

v0.7 dest count:35
v2 dest count:54

Is there an overlap in the generated polygon, is this also expected?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions