You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In reviewing the mpi-50-rc document, the following were identified as possible improvements in the document. Page and lines refer to the mpi-50-rc of February, 2025.
Improved Text:
p30: Replace "However, the examples have not been carefully checked or verified." with "However, while the examples have been reviewed, the MPI Forum does not guarantee that they do not contain any errors."
p 275, line 41. Change "MPI can be designed" to "An MPI implementation can be designed". The current text is incorrect, though the meaning is probably clear to readers.
p 299, line 5. Replace "dangerous" with "erroneous".
p 308, line 24. This text, "only communicators can be used in communication operations", dates from MPI-1. Note that MPI_WIN_POST and MPI_WIN_START take groups as arguments. Could just delete this clause.
p 515. Could explain the syntax of <...>; also in lines 37-44, there are < > where there could be some text, e.g.,
p 516. Example 11.18 has truly ancient systems. This could be modernized.
p 826, line 24 has an explicit page reference. Is that desirable?
p 1106. The introductory text doesn't explain that language-neutral examples are also listed in all caps (this is why I suggested that Fortran examples be listed in lower case, but the forum rejected that suggestion).
p 1108. Some examples don't appear to have routines associated with them. For example, Example 6.31 (or one near there).
p 1123. MPI_COUNT_KIND has two "primary" definitions. Should not be the one on p 874 (see the "Variable address size (Fortran only) table).
p 1129. MPI_Aint also has two primary definitions, on pages 21 and 131.
Proposal
Chapter committees to consider these suggestions
Changes to the Text
As noted above
Impact on Implementations
None
Impact on Users
Improved document
References and Pull Requests
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Problem
In reviewing the mpi-50-rc document, the following were identified as possible improvements in the document. Page and lines refer to the mpi-50-rc of February, 2025.
Improved Text:
Proposal
Chapter committees to consider these suggestions
Changes to the Text
As noted above
Impact on Implementations
None
Impact on Users
Improved document
References and Pull Requests
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: