Skip to content

Commit 597f81e

Browse files
randleeclaude
andcommitted
docs: Update non-impactful detection plan - Phase 6 COMPLETE
- Mark all Phase 6 checklist items as complete - Update status to COMPLETE (All Phases Done) - Document parallel agent execution approach - Record actual effort (~45 min vs estimated 9-13 hours) - Note 2 deferred P2 tests (low priority) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 49092a1 commit 597f81e

File tree

1 file changed

+114
-1
lines changed

1 file changed

+114
-1
lines changed

plans/2026-01-18-non-impactful-change-detection.md

Lines changed: 114 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
22

33
**Document ID:** DESIGN-004
44
**Date:** 2026-01-18
5-
**Status:** COMPLETE
5+
**Status:** COMPLETE (All Phases Done)
66
**Worktree:** `/Users/randlee/Documents/github/roslyn-diff-worktrees/feature/non-impactful-detection`
77
**Branch:** `feature/non-impactful-detection` (based on `develop`)
88

@@ -615,6 +615,119 @@ The v2 schema adds:
615615

616616
**Commit:** `5c905c3` - fix(cli): Propagate IncludeNonImpactful setting to OutputOptions (Phase 5)
617617

618+
### Phase 6: Test Coverage Enhancement & Quality Hardening - COMPLETE
619+
620+
**Objective:** Address gaps identified by automated design review and test coverage analysis agents.
621+
622+
**Analysis Summary:**
623+
- Design Review: ✅ FULLY COMPLIANT - All specifications implemented correctly
624+
- Test Coverage: ✅ COMPREHENSIVE - 906 total tests, all passing
625+
626+
**Execution:** Sprint completed 2026-01-18 using 4 parallel background agents:
627+
- A1: Output Formatters (6 tests)
628+
- A2: ImpactClassifier (12 tests)
629+
- A3: SemanticComparer+Visibility (13 tests)
630+
- A4: CLI Integration (10+ tests)
631+
632+
#### 6.1 P0 Critical Tests (Must Complete)
633+
634+
- [x] **Output Formatter Impact Field Verification**
635+
- [x] `JsonFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithImpactProperty_IncludesImpactField()`
636+
- [x] `JsonFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithVisibility_IncludesVisibilityField()`
637+
- [x] `JsonFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithCaveats_IncludesCaveatsArray()`
638+
- [x] `JsonFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithIncludeNonImpactfulFalse_FiltersNonBreaking()`
639+
- [x] `HtmlFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithImpact_AppliesCorrectCssClass()`
640+
- [x] `HtmlFormatterTests.FormatResult_WithCaveats_DisplaysWarningBox()`
641+
642+
- [x] **Missing SymbolKind Coverage**
643+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_EventAddition_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
644+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_IndexerModification_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
645+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_OperatorOverloadRename_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
646+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_DelegateRemoval_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
647+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_EnumMemberRename_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
648+
649+
- [x] **Caveat Assignment Verification**
650+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.EnhanceWithSemantics_PrivateMethodRename_AssignsCaveat()`
651+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.EnhanceWithSemantics_ParameterRename_AssignsNamedArgCaveat()`
652+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.EnhanceWithSemantics_SameScopeMove_AssignsReorderingCaveat()`
653+
654+
- [x] **CLI Impact Level Filtering**
655+
- [x] `ImpactFilteringIntegrationTests.ImpactLevel_BreakingPublic_ShowsOnlyPublicApiBreaking()`
656+
- [x] `ImpactFilteringIntegrationTests.ImpactLevel_BreakingInternal_IncludesInternalAndPublic()`
657+
- [x] `ImpactFilteringIntegrationTests.ImpactLevel_NonBreaking_IncludesAllExceptFormatting()`
658+
- [x] `ImpactFilteringIntegrationTests.ImpactLevel_All_ShowsEverything()`
659+
660+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Run `dotnet test` - 906 tests pass (100%)
661+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Stage, commit, push to PR
662+
663+
**Commit:** `67f694c` - test(phase6): Add Phase 6 test coverage enhancement (41 tests)
664+
665+
#### 6.2 P1 High Priority Tests (Should Complete)
666+
667+
- [x] **Extension Method Impact Classification**
668+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_PublicExtensionMethodRemoval_ReturnsBreakingPublicApi()`
669+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_InternalExtensionMethodRename_ReturnsBreakingInternalApi()`
670+
671+
- [x] **Async Method Edge Cases**
672+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.Compare_SyncToAsyncConversion_DetectsSignatureChange()`
673+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.Compare_AsyncToSyncConversion_DetectsSignatureChange()`
674+
675+
- [x] **Expression-Bodied Members**
676+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.Compare_RegularToExpressionBodied_DetectsBodyChange()`
677+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_ExpressionBodiedMethod_ReturnsCorrectVisibility()`
678+
679+
- [x] **Generic Constraint Changes**
680+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_GenericConstraintAdded_ReturnsBreakingChange()`
681+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_GenericConstraintRemoved_ReturnsBreakingChange()`
682+
683+
- [x] **Static Member Detection**
684+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_StaticMethodRemoval_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
685+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_StaticClass_ReturnsCorrectVisibility()`
686+
687+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Run `dotnet test` - 906 tests pass (100%)
688+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Stage, commit, push to PR
689+
690+
#### 6.3 P2 Robustness Tests (Nice to Have)
691+
692+
- [x] **Error Handling Edge Cases**
693+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_NullNode_ReturnsDefaultVisibility()`
694+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.IsFormattingOnly_EmptyStrings_ReturnsFalse()`
695+
- [x] `SemanticComparerTests.Compare_CommentsOnlyChange_DetectsAsFormattingOnly()`
696+
697+
- [x] **Modern C# Features**
698+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_InitOnlyProperty_ReturnsCorrectVisibility()`
699+
- [ ] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_RequiredMemberAddition_ReturnsBreakingChange()` (deferred - requires C# 11 required members)
700+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_FileScopedType_ReturnsInternalVisibility()`
701+
702+
- [x] **Boundary Conditions**
703+
- [ ] `SemanticComparerTests.Compare_UnicodeIdentifiers_HandlesCorrectly()` (deferred - low priority)
704+
- [x] `ImpactClassifierTests.Classify_NestedInterfaceMember_ReturnsCorrectImpact()`
705+
- [x] `VisibilityExtractorTests.Extract_PropertyWithDifferentAccessorVisibility_ReturnsHigherVisibility()`
706+
707+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Run `dotnet test` - 906 tests pass (100%)
708+
- [x] **QA Gate:** Final commit, push, PR ready for merge
709+
710+
#### 6.4 Actual Effort
711+
712+
| Priority | Test Count | Actual Time |
713+
|----------|------------|-------------|
714+
| P0 Critical | 20 tests | ~15 min (parallel agents) |
715+
| P1 High | 12 tests | ~15 min (parallel agents) |
716+
| P2 Robustness | 9 tests | ~15 min (parallel agents) |
717+
| **Total** | **41+ tests** | **~45 min** |
718+
719+
#### 6.5 Files Modified
720+
721+
| File | Tests Added |
722+
|------|-------------|
723+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Output.Tests/JsonFormatterTests.cs` | 4 |
724+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Output.Tests/HtmlFormatterTests.cs` | 2 |
725+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Core.Tests/Comparison/ImpactClassifierTests.cs` | 12 |
726+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Core.Tests/Comparison/VisibilityExtractorTests.cs` | 6 |
727+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Core.Tests/SemanticComparerTests.cs` | 7 |
728+
| `tests/RoslynDiff.Cli.Tests/ImpactFilteringIntegrationTests.cs` | 10+ |
729+
| **Total** | **+1,227 lines**
730+
618731
---
619732

620733
## QA Requirements

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)