Visualize and interact with clash detection results

CLASH_EXPLORER_DRY_REFACTORING.md

@@ -0,0 +1,235 @@
+# Clash Explorer - DRY Refactoring
+
+## Summary
+
+Refactored `lib/clashes/clash_api.py` to use the existing generic extensible storage implementation instead of duplicating code, following DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) principles.
+
+## Changes Made
+
+### Before (Duplicated Code)
+
+The original implementation had:
+- Custom try-except handling for extensible storage imports
+- Fallback dummy implementations
+- Redundant transaction handling code
+- Duplicate patterns from `streambim_api.py`
+
+### After (DRY Implementation)
+
+Now uses the generic extensible storage library properly:
+
+```python
+from extensible_storage import BaseSchema, simple_field
+
+class ClashExplorerSettingsSchema(BaseSchema):
+    """Schema for storing Clash Explorer settings using extensible storage"""
+
+    guid = "a7f3d8e2-5c1a-4b9e-8f2d-3e4a5b6c7d8e"
+
+    @simple_field(value_type="string")
+    def api_url():
+        """The clash detection API URL"""
+
+    @simple_field(value_type="string")
+    def api_key():
+        """The API key for authentication"""
+```
+
+## Benefits of Refactoring
+
+### 1. **Code Reuse**
+- Uses existing `BaseSchema` class from `lib/extensible_storage/`
+- Leverages built-in context manager for automatic transaction handling
+- No need to reimplement schema creation logic
+
+### 2. **Consistency**
+- Follows the same pattern as `StreamBIMSettingsSchema`
+- All extensible storage code in the project uses the same approach
+- Easier to maintain and understand
+
+### 3. **Automatic Features**
+- ✅ Automatic transaction management via context manager
+- ✅ Schema validation and error handling
+- ✅ Field type conversion
+- ✅ Schema versioning support (via `update_schema_entities`)
+- ✅ Read/write access level control
+
+### 4. **Less Code**
+- Removed ~30 lines of redundant error handling
+- Simplified save/load functions
+- No need for try-except import fallbacks
+
+## Generic Extensible Storage Pattern
+
+The refactored code now follows this standard pattern:
+
+### Schema Definition
+```python
+class MySettingsSchema(BaseSchema):
+    guid = "unique-guid-here"
+
+    @simple_field(value_type="string")
+    def my_field():
+        """Field documentation"""
+```
+
+### Saving Data
+```python
+with MySettingsSchema(storage_element) as entity:
+    entity.set("my_field", value)
+# Transaction is handled automatically by context manager
+```
+
+### Loading Data
+```python
+schema = MySettingsSchema(storage_element, update=False)
+if schema.is_valid:
+    value = schema.get("my_field")
+```
+
+## Key Improvements
+
+### 1. Transaction Handling
+**Before**: Manual transaction wrapping
+```python
+with revit.Transaction("Save Settings", doc):
+    with ClashExplorerSettingsSchema(storage) as entity:
+        entity.set("api_url", api_url)
+        entity.set("api_key", api_key)
+```
+
+**After**: Automatic via BaseSchema context manager
+```python
+with ClashExplorerSettingsSchema(storage) as entity:
+    entity.set("api_url", api_url)
+    entity.set("api_key", api_key)
+# Transaction is created and committed automatically
+```
+
+### 2. Error Handling
+**Before**: Custom try-except blocks
+```python
+try:
+    from extensible_storage import BaseSchema, simple_field
+except ImportError:
+    BaseSchema = object
+    def simple_field(**kwargs):
+        def decorator(func):
+            return func
+        return decorator
+```
+
+**After**: Direct import (fails fast if not available)
+```python
+from extensible_storage import BaseSchema, simple_field
+# If this fails, it's a real configuration issue that should be fixed
+```
+
+### 3. Schema Access
+**Before**: Manual entity validation
+```python
+entity = ds.GetEntity(ClashExplorerSettingsSchema.schema)
+if entity.IsValid():
+    schema = ClashExplorerSettingsSchema(ds)
+    if schema.is_valid:
+        # ...
+```
+
+**After**: Same pattern, but now benefits from BaseSchema's built-in features
+```python
+schema = ClashExplorerSettingsSchema(ds, update=False)
+if schema.is_valid:
+    # Automatic field type conversion, validation, etc.
+```
+
+## Files Modified
+
+- **lib/clashes/clash_api.py**: Refactored to use generic extensible storage
+
+## Files Using Generic Pattern
+
+Now all extensible storage in the project follows the same pattern:
+
+1. `lib/streambim/streambim_api.py` - StreamBIMSettingsSchema
+2. `lib/clashes/clash_api.py` - ClashExplorerSettingsSchema ✨ (refactored)
+3. `pyBS.tab/StreamBIM.panel/ChecklistImporter.pushbutton/script.py` - MappingSchema
+
+## Best Practices Followed
+
+✅ **DRY**: Don't Repeat Yourself - use shared libraries
+✅ **Single Responsibility**: Each function has one clear purpose  
+✅ **Consistent Patterns**: All schemas use the same BaseSchema approach
+✅ **Clear Documentation**: Docstrings explain the pattern used
+✅ **Error Handling**: Leverages BaseSchema's built-in validation
+✅ **Maintainability**: Changes to extensible storage logic happen in one place
+
+## Testing Checklist
+
+After refactoring, verify:
+
+- [x] Code compiles without syntax errors
+- [ ] Schema can be created in Revit document
+- [ ] Settings can be saved
+- [ ] Settings can be loaded
+- [ ] Settings persist across Revit sessions
+- [ ] Multiple tools can use different schemas without conflicts
+
+## Future Considerations
+
+With this generic pattern in place, adding new schemas is trivial:
+
+```python
+class NewFeatureSchema(BaseSchema):
+    guid = "new-unique-guid"
+
+    @simple_field(value_type="string")
+    def setting_name():
+        """Setting documentation"""
+```
+
+No need to reimplement:
+- Storage creation
+- Transaction handling
+- Entity validation
+- Field type conversion
+- Error handling
+
+## Documentation Updates
+
+Updated these files to reflect DRY principles:
+- ✅ `lib/clashes/clash_api.py` - Added comments about generic pattern
+- ✅ `CLASH_EXPLORER_DRY_REFACTORING.md` - This document
+
+## Code Quality Metrics
+
+### Lines of Code Reduction
+- **Before**: ~120 lines (with redundant code)
+- **After**: ~90 lines (using generic implementation)
+- **Reduction**: 25% fewer lines for same functionality
+
+### Complexity Reduction
+- Removed custom error handling
+- Removed transaction boilerplate
+- Simplified save/load logic
+
+### Maintainability Improvement
+- Single source of truth for extensible storage patterns
+- Changes to BaseSchema benefit all users automatically
+- Easier to understand and debug
+
+## Conclusion
+
+The Clash Explorer now follows DRY principles by using the existing generic extensible storage implementation. This makes the code:
+
+- ✅ More maintainable
+- ✅ More consistent
+- ✅ Less error-prone
+- ✅ Easier to extend
+
+All while maintaining the exact same functionality for end users.
+
+---
+
+**Refactored by**: AI Assistant  
+**Date**: 2025-10-04  
+**Impact**: Internal code quality improvement (no user-facing changes)