feat: tilejson metadata endpoints and tests (#20)

[mikemcdougall]

Pull Request

Issue Link

Fixes #20

Summary

Add TileJSON metadata + public MapLibre style discovery for layers. This branch also includes ongoing refactor changes already present from other agents.

Changes Made

• add TileJSON 3.0 metadata endpoint and public MapLibre style endpoint
• add TileJSON schema + MapLibre discovery integration tests
• update docs/examples for TileJSON + style
• include refactor adjustments already on this branch (FeatureServer/OData/Import/etc.)

Testing

• Unit tests added/updated
• Integration tests added/updated
• Architecture tests pass
• Local pre-PR validation passed (scripts/pre-pr-check.sh)

Coverage Impact

• Line coverage: not measured locally (see CI artifacts)
• Branch coverage: not measured locally (see CI artifacts)

Breaking Changes

None

Additional Context

• Pre-push validation ran full checks, including dotnet test -c Release Honua.sln -v:q
• PR includes other agents’ refactor changes already present on this branch

---

Pre-PR Checklist (for contributor)

• Ran scripts/pre-pr-check.sh and all checks passed
• Commit message follows format: type: description (#issue-number)
• PR title matches main commit message
• Issue number linked above
• Tests added for new functionality
• Documentation updated if needed

Reviewer Checklist

• Code follows project architecture (vertical slices, no controllers)
• Tests cover happy path and edge cases
• No reflection in hot paths (AOT compatible)
• Dependency limits respected (max 5 per endpoint)
• Error handling follows project patterns
• Security considerations addressed

[github-actions]

🤖 PR Template Validation

✅ All checks passed! Your PR follows the template correctly.

Next steps:

• Wait for CI to complete
• Address any feedback from LLM architecture review
• Request review from team members

---

Automated validation powered by GitHub Actions

[github-actions]

🤖 LLM Architecture Review

⚠️ Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

🏗️ Architecture Review Summary

Process Checks:

• ✅ Linked issue with acceptance criteria detected.
• ⚠️ Review limited to first 50 files; 35 file(s) not analyzed.

Diff Review Chunks: 53

Chunk 1/53 (src/Honua.Core/Features/Import/Domain/EsriImportRequest.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Features/Import/Domain/EsriImportRequest.cs:27 - Addition of JobId property with XML documentation.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes comply with the architectural rules: the added property is documented, and there are no issues with dependency direction, API patterns, encapsulation, AOT-safety, or excessive dependencies.

Chunk 2/53 (src/Honua.Core/Features/Import/Domain/ImportRequest.cs)

Findings

• No issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Chunk 3/53 (src/Honua.Core/Features/Infrastructure/IO/DelegatingStream.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Core/Features/Infrastructure/IO/DelegatingStream.cs:9 - DelegatingStream should be internal to enforce encapsulation of infrastructure implementation types.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 4/53 (src/Honua.Core/Features/Infrastructure/Memory/PooledGeometryProcessor.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Core/Features/Infrastructure/Memory/PooledGeometryProcessor.cs:1 - Honua.Core should not reference Honua.Core.Features.Infrastructure.IO if it is part of a different module or layer that reverses the intended dependency direction.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Features/Infrastructure/Memory/PooledGeometryProcessor.cs:113-114 - Refactoring to use DelegatingStream simplifies the implementation and maintains the internal encapsulation of infrastructure types.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The addition of a potentially cross-module dependency needs clarification or adjustment to adhere to the architectural rules regarding dependency direction.

Chunk 5/53 (src/Honua.Core/Features/Shared/Models/JsonElementConverter.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Core/Features/Shared/Models/JsonElementConverter.cs:1-52 - Usage of dynamic JSON conversion which is not AOT-safe.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 6/53 (src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2JsonParser.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2JsonParser.cs:190 - Refactoring to use a helper method improves modularity and reuse.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2JsonParser.cs:354-372 - Removal of private method in favor of using a centralized helper method is a good practice for reducing code duplication and improving maintainability.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff are consistent with good software architecture practices, including promoting code reuse and maintainability without introducing any new architectural issues. The refactoring aligns with the principles of encapsulation and modular design.

Chunk 7/53 (src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2Parser.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2Parser.cs:180,189 - Refactored to use FilterExpressionHelpers.BuildBetweenExpression, improving code reusability and maintainability.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/Cql2/Cql2Parser.cs:237-255 - Removed BuildBetweenExpression method from Cql2Parser and centralized it in FilterExpressionHelpers, adhering to DRY principles.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules, improve code organization, and maintain compliance with the required patterns.

Chunk 8/53 (src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/FilterExpressionHelpers.cs)

Findings

• No issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The diff shows the addition of an internal static class within the Honua.Core namespace, which adheres to the encapsulation rule by being marked as internal. The methods within do not use any disallowed features such as reflection or dynamic JSON, and they are appropriate for AOT scenarios. There are no ControllerBase or ApiController usages, and the file does not introduce any dependency direction issues. The class is focused on building expressions and does not exceed dependency count limits.

Chunk 9/53 (src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/GeoServicesSql/GeoServicesSqlParser.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/GeoServicesSql/GeoServicesSqlParser.cs:98,119 - Refactoring to use FilterExpressionHelpers.BuildBetweenExpression maintains encapsulation and improves code reuse.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Core/Queries/Filters/GeoServicesSql/GeoServicesSqlParser.cs:345-372 - Removal of private method BuildBetweenExpression in favor of a centralized method improves maintainability and reduces duplication.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes made in the diff are consistent with the architecture rules of Honua, focusing on improving code reusability and maintainability without introducing any architectural or AOT compliance issues.

Chunk 10/53 (src/Honua.Postgres/Features/FeatureStore/PostgresFeatureStoreRefactored.cs)

Findings

• None

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Rationale:

• The changes are within Honua.Postgres, which is allowed to depend on Honua.Core. There are no new dependencies introduced in the diff.
• The modified class PostgresFeatureStoreRefactored is marked as internal, adhering to the encapsulation rule.
• There are no uses of ControllerBase or ApiController; the file is not related to API controllers but to a feature store implementation.
• The methods RemoveInternalAttributes for Feature and GmlFeature do not use reflection or dynamic JSON; they manipulate data structures in a way that should be AOT-safe.
• The changes do not introduce sync-over-async issues.
• The file does not exceed the dependency count limits as per the diff provided.
• Public XML documentation is not required for internal types, and the public API documentation requirement is thus not applicable here.

Chunk 11/53 (src/Honua.Postgres/Features/FeatureStore/Services/FeatureCacheManager.cs)

Findings

• No issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Chunk 12/53 (src/Honua.Postgres/Features/FeatureStore/Services/FeatureDataAccess.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Postgres/Features/FeatureStore/Services/FeatureDataAccess.cs:1173 - Refactoring to use JsonElementConverter.ConvertToScalar improves code readability and potentially reusability.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

This change does not introduce any architectural violations or issues with AOT compatibility. It refactors existing code to use a potentially centralized method for JSON element conversion, which could enhance maintainability and consistency across the project.

Chunk 13/53 (src/Honua.Postgres/Features/Import/EsriImportService.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Postgres/Features/Import/EsriImportService.cs - The changes maintain internal encapsulation and use source-generated JSON/logging.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Postgres/Features/Import/EsriImportService.cs - The modification to use an existing JobId if provided and to track startedAt consistently improves the functionality without introducing architectural issues.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes are compliant with the Honua architecture rules, focusing on internal encapsulation, avoiding sync-over-async issues, and maintaining AOT-friendly patterns. The modifications enhance functionality without introducing new dependencies or violating encapsulation and dependency direction rules.

Chunk 14/53 (src/Honua.Server/EndpointRegistry.cs)

Findings

• No issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Explanation: The changes in the EndpointRegistry.cs file simply add two new GET endpoints to the server's endpoint registry. These additions comply with the use of Minimal APIs (no ControllerBase or [ApiController] used), and there are no violations of dependency directions, encapsulation, AOT patterns, or public XML documentation requirements in the diff provided. The changes do not introduce sync-over-async issues or exceed dependency count limits.

Chunk 15/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs - Refactored validation logic into a helper class, maintaining minimal API usage.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs - Uses dependency injection to retrieve services, adhering to encapsulation rules.
• [APROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs - No ControllerBase or [ApiController] usage, compliant with the minimal API pattern.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs - Removal of direct error message handling in favor of using a helper method improves maintainability and encapsulation.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/AttachmentEndpoints.cs - No evidence of sync-over-async patterns or excessive dependencies in the modified code.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules set for Honua, maintain minimal API usage, and improve code maintainability and encapsulation without introducing any new issues.

Chunk 16/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerEditsHandler.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerEditsHandler.cs - Refactoring uses Minimal API patterns and encapsulates logic within internal types.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerEditsHandler.cs - AOT-safe patterns are maintained with source-generated logging and no dynamic JSON.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerEditsHandler.cs - Dependency direction is maintained; no new dependencies on Honua.Core or inappropriate layers.
• [APROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerEditsHandler.cs - Encapsulation is adhered to with internal visibility for infrastructure types.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules of Honua, focusing on proper encapsulation, AOT-safe patterns, and the use of Minimal APIs. The refactoring simplifies error handling and validation logic, improving maintainability without introducing any new architectural concerns.

Chunk 17/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerMetadataHandlers.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerMetadataHandlers.cs - Refactoring to use a helper method for validation maintains compliance with architectural rules and improves code readability.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff simplify the validation logic and error handling by using a helper method, which centralizes the validation logic and error reporting. This change adheres to the architectural rules regarding minimal API usage, AOT-safe patterns, and internal encapsulation. There are no violations of dependency direction, and the use of source-generated logging is maintained. The refactoring does not introduce any new dependencies or sync-over-async issues.

Chunk 18/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs:20 - FeatureServerQueryHandler should be internal but is missing the internal keyword.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs:64 - FeatureServerResourceValidationHelpers seems to be a utility class used for encapsulation but should be internal.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs:541 - FeatureServerSpatialFilterBuilder should be internal if it is an infrastructure implementation type.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs:63 - Dependency count might be too high; review needed to confirm the exact number of dependencies.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerQueryHandler.cs:327 - Conversion method ToExtentInfo should be checked if it uses AOT-safe patterns.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The main issues are related to encapsulation and internal visibility of infrastructure types, which is critical for maintaining the architecture's integrity. Additionally, the potential high dependency count in the FeatureServerQueryHandler constructor needs review.

Chunk 19/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerRelatedRecordsHandler.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] No specific issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Explanation:

• Dependency Direction: The changes in the diff do not introduce any new dependencies that violate the architectural rules.
• Minimal API Usage: The code does not introduce ControllerBase or [ApiController], adhering to the use of Minimal APIs.
• Infrastructure Encapsulation: The types modified or used in the diff are marked as internal, which complies with the encapsulation requirement.
• AOT-safe Patterns: The diff does not introduce reflection or dynamic JSON usage. It continues to use source-generated logging and structured error handling.
• Public XML Docs: There is no introduction of new public types that would require XML documentation.
• Dependency Count Limits: The diff does not show an increase in dependencies that would violate the limits set by the architecture rules.
• Sync-over-Async: There is no evidence of synchronous over asynchronous programming patterns like .Result or .Wait() in the diff.

The refactoring in the diff improves clarity and maintains compliance with the established architectural rules.

Chunk 20/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerRequestHandlers.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerRequestHandlers.cs:345 - Refactoring to use a centralized validation helper (LayerValidationHelpers.ValidateLayerWithAccessAsync) which simplifies the code and potentially reduces duplication.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerRequestHandlers.cs:344, 345 - Removal of direct service resolution (GetRequiredService<IResourceValidator>()) in favor of dependency injection through method parameters in the helper method, aligning with better encapsulation and dependency management practices.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules of Honua, improve code maintainability, and do not introduce any new issues related to dependency direction, encapsulation, or AOT safety. The use of Minimal APIs and internal visibility for infrastructure types is maintained.

Chunk 21/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerResourceValidationHelpers.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerResourceValidationHelpers.cs - The file correctly defines internal types for infrastructure-related helpers, adhering to encapsulation rules.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerResourceValidationHelpers.cs - Uses source-generated logging methods (FeatureServerLog.ServiceNotFound, FeatureServerLog.LayerNotFound), aligning with AOT-safe patterns.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerResourceValidationHelpers.cs - No ControllerBase or [ApiController] is used; follows the Minimal API usage rule.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules set for Honua, including proper encapsulation of infrastructure types, adherence to AOT-safe patterns, and compliance with the Minimal API strategy.

Chunk 22/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs:6 - Dependency direction violation: Honua.Server should not reference Honua.Core.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs:152 - Encapsulation violation: Infrastructure implementation type FeatureServerEndpoints must be internal.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs:206 - Sync-over-async pattern detected with ConfigureAwait(false).
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs:152,192 - AOT violation: Reflection or dynamic JSON usage suspected in mapping functions.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/FeatureServerUtilities.cs:152,192 - Missing XML documentation for public methods.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 23/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/FeatureServerSpatialFilterBuilder.cs)

Findings

• None

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The diff adheres to the Honua architecture rules:

• The new file FeatureServerSpatialFilterBuilder.cs is correctly marked as internal, ensuring encapsulation of infrastructure implementation.
• The use of static methods for building spatial filters aligns with the minimal API pattern, avoiding ControllerBase or [ApiController].
• The code does not introduce any new dependencies that violate the dependency direction rules.
• There are no signs of sync-over-async issues or excessive dependencies in the provided code.
• The file does not use reflection or dynamic JSON, which complies with AOT-safe patterns.

Chunk 24/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryBuilding/StandardFeatureQueryBuilder.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryBuilding/StandardFeatureQueryBuilder.cs:6 - Honua.Server.Features.FeatureServer.Services should not be referenced in Honua.Server.Features.FeatureServer.Services.QueryBuilding as it suggests a circular dependency.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryBuilding/StandardFeatureQueryBuilder.cs:83-86 - Refactored code uses FeatureServerSpatialFilterBuilder.BuildSpatialFilter which seems to be a new dependency not shown in the diff. If it's a new class, it must be internal and properly encapsulated.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryBuilding/StandardFeatureQueryBuilder.cs:83-86 - Dependency on FeatureServerSpatialFilterBuilder increases the dependency count which needs review for potential violation of the dependency count limit.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 25/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryFormatters.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryFormatters.cs:496-498 - Removal of ILogger dependency might violate AOT-safe logging practices if not replaced or documented.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FeatureServer/Services/QueryFormatters.cs:496-498 - Dependency reduction in constructor might indicate a shift from a layered organization to vertical slices, needs review to ensure alignment with architectural goals.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

Chunk 26/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/AwsS3FileStorage.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/AwsS3FileStorage.cs - Refactoring to use helper methods (ReportCancelledUploadAsync, ReportFailedUploadAsync, ValidatePresignedUploadArguments) improves code readability and maintainability without introducing new architectural issues.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules of Honua, including proper encapsulation of infrastructure implementation, adherence to AOT-safe patterns, and no violations of dependency directions or API patterns. The refactoring enhances code clarity and reusability without adding new dependencies or breaking existing patterns.

Chunk 27/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/AzureBlobFileStorage.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/AzureBlobFileStorage.cs - Refactoring to use helper methods (ReportCancelledUploadAsync, ReportFailedUploadAsync, ValidatePresignedUploadArguments) improves code readability and maintainability without introducing new architectural issues.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules set for the Honua project. The refactoring maintains the internal visibility of infrastructure implementation, uses appropriate exception handling, and avoids sync-over-async issues. There are no violations of dependency directions, and the changes do not introduce ControllerBase or ApiController, which aligns with the requirement to use Minimal APIs. Additionally, the refactoring does not appear to introduce any new dependencies that would violate the dependency count limits.

Chunk 28/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CancellableReadStream.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CancellableReadStream.cs - The class CancellableReadStream is correctly marked as internal, ensuring encapsulation of infrastructure implementation.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CancellableReadStream.cs - Refactoring to inherit from DelegatingStream simplifies the implementation by removing the need to manually delegate each method to the inner stream, which is a good practice for maintainability and error reduction.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CancellableReadStream.cs - The use of constructor chaining (: base(inner)) to initialize the base class promotes code reuse and reduces redundancy.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules of Honua, maintain encapsulation, and improve code quality by leveraging inheritance to reduce redundancy.

Chunk 29/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CloudFileStorageBase.cs)

Findings

• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CloudFileStorageBase.cs:191 - Sync-over-async pattern detected (CancellationToken.None used in an async method).
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/CloudFileStorageBase.cs:191, 228 - Use of CancellationToken.None instead of propagating an existing CancellationToken might lead to unresponsive tasks during application shutdown or other cancel events.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

The issues identified are not blocking but should be addressed to improve the robustness and responsiveness of the application, especially under cancellation scenarios. The use of CancellationToken.None in asynchronous methods should be replaced with appropriate cancellation tokens.

Chunk 30/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/FileStorageLog.cs)

Findings

• None

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules:

• The added logging method ProgressUpdateFailed uses source-generated logging, which is AOT-safe.
• The type FileStorageLog is internal, maintaining proper encapsulation.
• There are no issues with dependency direction, XML documentation requirements (not required for internal types), or excessive dependencies.
• The change does not introduce any sync-over-async issues.

Chunk 31/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/LocalFileStorage.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/LocalFileStorage.cs:93 - Use of async lambda without awaiting the result can lead to unobserved task exceptions.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/LocalFileStorage.cs:165, 182, 350 - Method ReportCancelledUploadAsync and ReportFailedUploadAsync are likely async but called with await inside a catch block which should be avoided to prevent context capture and potential deadlocks.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/LocalFileStorage.cs:93 - Dependency on ProgressStore and Logger inside LocalFileStorage class might be too high, consider reducing or managing dependencies more effectively.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/LocalFileStorage.cs:93 - The refactoring into separate methods for error handling (ReportProgressAsync, ReportCancelledUploadAsync, ReportFailedUploadAsync) could indicate a violation of the single responsibility principle if these methods handle more than just logging/reporting.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The use of async operations within synchronous contexts and the potential over-complication of class responsibilities need addressing to comply with best practices and architectural guidelines.

Chunk 32/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/ResponseDisposingStream.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/ResponseDisposingStream.cs - The class ResponseDisposingStream is correctly marked as internal, ensuring encapsulation.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/ResponseDisposingStream.cs - Inherits from DelegatingStream which simplifies the implementation by removing the need to manually delegate each method to the inner stream.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/ResponseDisposingStream.cs - Proper use of constructor chaining (: base(inner)) to initialize base class, reducing redundancy.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/FileStorage/ResponseDisposingStream.cs - Correct disposal pattern in both Dispose(bool disposing) and DisposeAsync() methods, ensuring that both the inner stream and the response are disposed.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes are compliant with the architectural rules, improve code simplicity, and maintain proper encapsulation and disposal patterns.

Chunk 33/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportBackgroundService.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportBackgroundService.cs:6 - Honua.Core.Features.Import.Domain should not be referenced from Honua.Server to maintain proper dependency direction.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportBackgroundService.cs:Various - The EsriImportBackgroundService class seems to have a high number of dependencies and complex logic, which could indicate a violation of the dependency count limits and potentially a need for refactoring towards a more vertical slice architecture.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportBackgroundService.cs:Various - Extensive use of ConfigureAwait(false) in a server environment typically managed by ASP.NET Core's context might be unnecessary unless explicitly handling a specific scenario that requires it.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The primary issue is the improper dependency direction, which needs resolution to adhere to the architectural rules of the Honua project. Additionally, the complexity and potential overuse of ConfigureAwait(false) should be reviewed and possibly refactored.

Chunk 34/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportEndpoints.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportEndpoints.cs:221 - Modification of EsriImportRequest by adding JobId without corresponding XML documentation for the public type.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportEndpoints.cs:333 - Added logic to check IsActiveStatus could potentially increase dependencies within the method; review needed to ensure dependency count limits are maintained.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportEndpoints.cs:258 - Correctly updated URLs to be more specific, improving API usability without introducing any architectural issues.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/EsriImportEndpoints.cs:374,403 - Conditional check on progress.Status using IsActiveStatus method is a good encapsulation of status logic.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

The addition of a new property to a public type without proper documentation is a blocking issue that needs resolution. Other changes are well-aligned with architectural rules.

Chunk 35/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/ImportEndpoints.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/ImportEndpoints.cs:331-343 - Use of async void in lambda expression for Progress<UploadProgress> constructor. This can lead to unhandled exceptions and poor error handling.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/ImportEndpoints.cs:331-343 - Potential sync-over-async issue with progress => _ = ReportProgressAsync(progress). This pattern can lead to thread pool exhaustion under high load.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 36/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs (part 1/3))

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs:32 - _jobQueue initialization removed dependency on IDistributedCache which is not documented in the diff context. Ensure dependency direction and encapsulation are maintained.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs:40 - _requestStore initialization added redis parameter, altering dependency without clear documentation or reasoning in the diff context.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs:60 - RedisJobQueue class seems to be handling multiple responsibilities (queue management, fallback handling, Redis connection restoration), which might violate the single responsibility principle.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs:85 - Sync-over-async potential issue with extensive use of ConfigureAwait(false) in a context that might not need it, depending on the broader application design.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs:161 - The method GetQueueLengthAsync combines lengths from Redis and fallback queue, which could be a sign of overly complex method design.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The changes introduce potential architectural violations regarding dependency direction and encapsulation. Additionally, the complexity in handling Redis connectivity and fallback mechanisms might need further review to ensure they align with clean architecture and single responsibility principles.

Chunk 37/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs (part 2/3))

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs - The RedisImportJobManager and RedisProgressStore<T> classes are internal, which is compliant with encapsulation rules. However, there is extensive use of async/await without proper handling of ConfigureAwait, which could lead to deadlocks in certain synchronization contexts.
• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs - The use of _redisDb and _redis suggests direct dependency on Redis, which should be abstracted behind interfaces to adhere to the dependency inversion principle and to maintain a clean architecture.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs - The methods EnsureRedisLeadershipAsync and TryRestoreRedisAsync contain multiple await statements, which could indicate a high number of dependencies or complex logic that should be simplified or broken down.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs - The use of Log static class directly for logging inside catch blocks should be replaced with dependency-injected logging to adhere to AOT-friendly patterns and dependency inversion principles.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The code needs refactoring to reduce direct dependencies, ensure proper async handling, and adhere to AOT-friendly logging practices.

Chunk 38/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs (part 3/3))

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/RedisImportJobManager.cs - No architectural rule violations found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff:

• Use of Task.FromResult to return a task without async operation is acceptable and does not constitute sync-over-async.
• LoggerMessage attribute usage adheres to AOT-safe patterns by using source-generated logging.
• The changes are localized to the Honua.Server project, maintaining proper dependency direction.
• The Log class is likely internal, adhering to encapsulation rules, though this cannot be confirmed from the diff alone. Assuming compliance based on typical patterns.
• No ControllerBase or ApiController patterns are introduced.

Chunk 39/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs (part 1/2))

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs:11 - StackExchange.Redis dependency in Honua.Server violates the dependency direction rule. Honua.Core should not be dependent on external packages in Honua.Server.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs:19 - UniversalProgressStore class is internal, which is good, but it should ensure all methods not intended for public use are also marked as internal or private.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs:various - The class seems to handle a lot of responsibilities (caching, logging, Redis operations, fallback handling), suggesting a review for possible violation of single responsibility principle and dependency count limits.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

The introduction of a direct dependency on StackExchange.Redis in the Honua.Server project is a critical architectural violation that must be addressed. Additionally, the complexity and responsibilities of the UniversalProgressStore class should be reviewed to ensure compliance with architectural best practices.

Chunk 40/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs (part 2/2))

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs - The method MatchesOperationTypeAsync uses Enum.TryParse which can potentially break AOT compatibility due to reflection. Consider using a source-generated approach or a predefined mapping.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Import/UniversalProgressStore.cs - The method MatchesOperationTypeAsync involves multiple asynchronous calls to a database, which could indicate a high number of dependencies or complex logic that might be better handled in a separate service or layer.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

Chunk 41/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Helpers/TemporalExtentHelpers.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Helpers/TemporalExtentHelpers.cs:1-174 - Infrastructure implementation types must be internal; however, the method ResolveTemporalFieldsOrThrow is public.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Helpers/TemporalExtentHelpers.cs:1-174 - TryResolveTemporalRangeAsync method uses async-await with ConfigureAwait(false) which is good, but the method complexity and dependency on IFeatureReader might suggest a high dependency count and intricate logic that could benefit from simplification or refactoring.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

Chunk 42/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Hosting/FeatureRegistrationExtensions.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] No specific issues detected in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules:

• No ControllerBase or [ApiController] usage, consistent with the requirement for Minimal APIs.
• The modified types are internal, maintaining proper encapsulation.
• The changes do not introduce any apparent AOT-unsafe patterns.
• Dependency direction is maintained as the modifications are within the Honua.Server project.
• There is no evidence of sync-over-async issues in the diff provided.
• The number of dependencies in the modified file does not appear to exceed the set limits based on the diff context.

Chunk 43/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/ProtocolErrorWriter.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/ProtocolErrorWriter.cs:various - Moved logic to ProtocolRequestClassifier which might indicate a new dependency or inappropriate responsibility shift if not managed correctly.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/ProtocolErrorWriter.cs:various - Refactoring to use ProtocolRequestClassifier increases dependency count for ProtocolErrorWriter, potentially violating the dependency count limits.

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

The changes suggest a shift of responsibilities to a new or existing class (ProtocolRequestClassifier). This needs careful review to ensure it doesn't introduce inappropriate dependencies or exceed recommended dependency limits. The refactoring itself is not inherently problematic, but the context and implementation of ProtocolRequestClassifier need verification to ensure compliance with architectural rules.

Chunk 44/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/ProtocolRequestClassifier.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/ProtocolRequestClassifier.cs:1-69 - The file correctly defines an internal static class, adhering to encapsulation rules for infrastructure implementation types. The methods use AOT-safe patterns without reflection or dynamic JSON.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The new file adheres to the architectural rules set for Honua, including correct encapsulation of infrastructure types, use of internal visibility, and AOT-safe coding practices. No ControllerBase or ApiController patterns are used, and the file is part of the Honua.Server project, which is allowed to depend on Honua.Core. There are no issues with dependency direction, excessive dependencies, or sync-over-async patterns in this diff.

Chunk 45/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/StandardErrorResponseFormatter.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Models/StandardErrorResponseFormatter.cs - Refactoring to use ProtocolRequestClassifier improves modularity and reusability of protocol classification logic.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

This refactoring centralizes protocol and error code mapping logic into a ProtocolRequestClassifier, which is a good practice for maintainability and potentially reduces errors by centralizing logic used across multiple parts of the application. The changes adhere to the architectural rules of encapsulation, AOT safety, and minimal API usage. There are no violations of dependency direction, and the internal visibility of the StandardErrorResponseFormatter class is maintained.

Chunk 46/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Monitoring/ObservabilityServiceCollectionExtensions.cs)

Findings

• No issues found in the provided diff.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff adhere to the architectural rules:

• The extension method is correctly marked as internal, ensuring proper encapsulation.
• The addition of caching policies for "TileJson" and "LayerStyle" does not involve any ControllerBase, APIController attributes, or reflection/dynamic JSON usage.
• There is no indication of improper dependency direction, sync-over-async patterns, or excessive dependencies in this specific change.

Chunk 47/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/GeoServicesToMapLibreConverter.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/GeoServicesToMapLibreConverter.cs - The class is marked as internal, which is compliant with encapsulation rules.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/GeoServicesToMapLibreConverter.cs - Removal of direct CultureInfo usage in parsing and delegation to a helper class (StyleParsingHelpers) aligns with AOT-safe patterns.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes adhere to the architectural rules by improving AOT compatibility and maintaining proper encapsulation of infrastructure components. The use of a helper class for parsing also potentially reduces duplication and centralizes parsing logic, which is a good practice.

Chunk 48/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/MapLibreToGeoServicesConverter.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] No issues found in the diff regarding dependency direction, minimal API usage, encapsulation, AOT safety, public XML documentation, dependency count limits, or sync-over-async issues.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The changes in the diff focus on refactoring the TryGetDouble method usage to a centralized helper class StyleParsingHelpers, which is consistent with DRY principles and does not introduce any architectural or compliance issues based on the provided rules. The internal visibility and static nature of the MapLibreToGeoServicesConverter class are maintained, and no new external dependencies or inappropriate patterns (like sync-over-async) are introduced.

Chunk 49/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleEndpoints.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleEndpoints.cs - The file adheres to the Minimal API usage, avoiding ControllerBase or [ApiController].
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleEndpoints.cs - Infrastructure implementation type StyleEndpoints is correctly declared as internal.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleEndpoints.cs - Uses source-generated JSON (StyleJsonContext.Default.JsonElement) for serialization, complying with AOT-safe patterns.
• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleEndpoints.cs - No excessive dependencies in endpoint handlers; dependencies are within limits.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The diff adheres to the architectural rules of Honua, including proper encapsulation, AOT-safe practices, and minimal API usage. The dependencies are managed well, and the internal visibility of the infrastructure type is correctly implemented.

Chunk 50/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleParsingHelpers.cs)

Findings

• [APPROVED] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Styling/StyleParsingHelpers.cs:1-30 - The file adheres to the rules: internal type for infrastructure, uses source-generated JSON, and handles culture appropriately with CultureInfo.InvariantCulture.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Chunk 51/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/LayerValidationHelpers.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/LayerValidationHelpers.cs:86 - LayerValidationHelpers class should be internal but contains a public method ValidateLayerWithAccessAsync.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/LayerValidationHelpers.cs:86 - Dependency on IResourceValidator and AccessPolicyHelpers may indicate too many dependencies for a single class.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Chunk 52/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/QueryParameterValidationHelpers.cs)

Findings

• None

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

Rationale:

• The file QueryParameterValidationHelpers.cs is correctly placed within the Honua.Server project and is marked as internal, which adheres to the encapsulation rule for infrastructure implementation types.
• The usage of ICommonQueryValidator from Honua.Core in Honua.Server is compliant with the dependency direction rule, as Honua.Server can depend on Honua.Core.
• The methods are static and utility-based, which fits well within the minimal API strategy, avoiding the use of controllers.
• There are no signs of sync-over-async issues, reflection, or dynamic JSON usage in the provided code, making it AOT-safe.
• The file does not exceed the dependency count limits as it only uses a few dependencies.
• Public XML documentation is not required here as the type is internal.

Chunk 53/53 (src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/ValidationExtensions.cs)

Findings

• [BLOCKING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/ValidationExtensions.cs:308 - Use of reflection-like dynamic JSON conversion which is not AOT-safe.
• [WARNING] src/Honua.Server/Features/Infrastructure/Validation/ValidationExtensions.cs:6 - Dependency on Honua.Core.Features.Shared.Models might indicate too many dependencies or inappropriate layering.

Overall Assessment: BLOCKING_ISSUES

Overall Assessment: NEEDS_ATTENTION

---

Automated architectural analysis powered by OpenAI GPT-4
This review focuses on architectural patterns and design decisions
Human review still recommended for complex changes