Hello! I'm a first-time contributor, and I'm interested in taking a look at this issue. My initial thought is to maybe create a share link with view permissions for the project by default. Could you provide more details on how to navigate this? And any tips on improving the share link would be appreciated!

Not sure. If we create one the same way user creates them, its going to be in the list without explicitely telling user why it's there. Potentially we would need a special link that is either not shown in the share dialog or is shown but rendered in a special way with a tooltip that communicates what it is and that it can't be deleted if project is in the marketplace. Maybe it makes sense to not show it at all there.

Hi @kof ! I was thinking about some other solutions, and I wanted to get your thoughts on some ideas below,

1. Similar to what you mentioned, maybe we can hide the "Open project" button, and display a message near it letting other users know to contact the author so they can view the project as a separate link. There are two options for this approach, we can hide the Open project button or keep it there,
   
   

2. Generally I think we should use 1. and 2. together, I think it would be helpful for users that are submitting to the Marketplace to have an option to automatically create a share link -- maybe a checkbox?
   

Additionally, I noticed that there is already a tooltip that indicates the reason for the disabled button, perhaps we can make the message more descriptive if the other options above aren't possible?

Let me know what you think, thanks!

I still think that the share link should be just generated always by default and not showed in the share dialog at all or show it so it can be copied but make it non-deleatable and renamable.

I see, thank you for the clarification! I'll begin working on generating the share link by default when you upload a project to the marketplace, and we can decide later whether to show/hide the marketplace link in the share dialog

@kof Hello! I started working on this feature, and I currently implemented some changes so when you click Project Settings > Marketplace > Start Review, it will create a new share link called Marketplace Link (currently visible),

And when you click Unlist from Marketplace, it removes the share link.

I was thinking that it might actually be better if the share link wasn't visible at all in the dialog so it's a little more backwards compatible with users that have already published their projects to the marketplace.

I also have a few questions below and would like to know your thoughts about them,

1. What is the best way to "hide" the link in the share dialog?
   • one suggestion is to add a new field to the token called "marketplaceLink" with a boolean value,
   • maybe using a unique name (which is what I have implemented right now, but it doesn't seem like the best solution in case the user creates another link with the same name)
2. Is this a good place to create the share link or would it be better to create the share link after the project is approved?
3. A follow up to the previous question, how is a project approved for the Marketplace?

Thank you!