WP1.2 Coordination Meeting March 19, 2020

Meeting Report WP1.2 ‘Modelica library for MPC’

1. MEETING SUBJECT, DATE

Subject: WP1.2

Date: 19-03-2020

Location: Skype for Business

Minutes taken by: Lieve Helsen (KU Leuven)

2. PARTICIPANTS

Company/Organisation - Participant

KU Leuven - Lieve Helsen (WP Leader)

KU Leuven - Filip Jorissen

KU Leuven - Iago Cupeiro

LBNL - David Blum

Politecnico de Milano - Ettore Zanetti

SINTEF - Harald Taxt Walnum

PNNL - Sen Huang

SDU - Toa yang

ENGIE - Valentin Gavan

Oak Ridge national Lab – ORNL (US) - Yeonjin Bae

3. AGENDA and REPORT

3.1. Approval/Modification Agenda

Approved

3.2. Status & further discussion where needed

a. Emulators:

4 models selected to start MPC testing

i. BESTEST Air (LBNL/KU Leuven):

Dave addressed Filip’s comments, can be finalized now by pull request (action Dave).

ii. BESTEST Hydronic (KU Leuven /LBNL):

Javier did the test case data generation. Filip, Dave and Javier had some discussion about the system which is very simple (1 zone, pump, radiator and water supply temperature that can be controlled, pump on/off): TRV to be added? No, since no control degree of freedom then. Filip is finalizing the model, Dave works on the documentation and review.

iii. 8-Zone Residential Hydronic (Engie/SDU):

Emulator has been finalized and is BOPTEST ready. Check whether it is available on BOPTEST repository, make pull request (action Valentin).

iv. Multi-Zone Office Hybrid Simple (KU Leuven/Engie):

all issues have been resolved, Valentin has reviewed the emulator, works well, comments have been sent to Iago. Congrats Iago ;-) No success yet in testing within the BOPTEST environment. Action Iago & Javier: make the model BOP-TEST ready

However further progress has been made in other models too!

v. Single-Zone Commercial Building (SDU):

ready and put on the BOPTEST repository, pull request made. Dave takes a look at it.

vi. Multi-Zone Air-Based Prototype Complex (PNNL):

Model sent by Sen to Iago for review. To be reviewed by Iago.

Emulators need to be put on BOP-TEST repository in the directory Testcases

Do we need a copy of the IDEAS library in that repository? No, the model should be there and they can call libraries, which should be available locally or in the docker container. Compile FMU in BOPTEST repository, should be done in a systematic way (including dependencies needed) by using versions.

Extra emulator that will be developed: Flexible Research Platform by ORNL: 10 zones office, VAV system. Emulator will be made by ORNL. Reviewer still to be assigned.

Emulators overview:

b. KPIs - scenarios

Choice between TMYx (1946-2018) and TMY3 (1973-2005) weather files. We have a data reader for TMY3 in IBPSA. Both will be compared in the representative days/weeks selection (action PNNL). No update.

c. BOPTEST:

i. Specify zone name in multi-zone buildings (Dave, Javier):

IBPSA Modelica Library had an update regarding the zone name designation to the measurement read block, which gives more flexibility to multi-zone buildings (done by Dave). Corresponding update in BOPTEST has been implemented in pull request by Javier. A test case is now being set up to check whether it works properly.

ii. Indoor air quality KPI (Dave):

CO2 concentration for IAQ KPI (in ppm-hours) has been implemented in the KPI calculator in BOPTEST, and merged by Dave.

iii. Historical data for training (Qi Li and Dave):

Qi Li and Dave discussed about the generation of new weather files based on historical data, to be used for grey and black box model identification (training data that differ from test data). To be continued.

iv. Technical Advisory Group meeting:

Technical Advisory Group meeting for US part in a few weeks about implementing the test case, some feedback is expected (Dave).

d. MPC Library (IbpsaMpc):

i. JModelica

JModelica is no longer open source, but we do not expect problems on the short term, so we’ll continue.

ii. Unit testing framework (action Dave):

No progress

e. Dissemination:

Broaden the user space (e.g. to Machine Learning people). How to reach these people? Action Jan: make a first suggestion. Cfr OpenAIGym, no update

3.3. Initiatives joint papers

a. MPC Review paper: Lieve finalized the final review and send this to Jan.

3.4. Next phase

a. Finalize first set of emulators by next progress meeting in April

b. Start testing your controller(s) on the emulators and share your comments, remarks, suggestions for improvement.

c. In the meantime the development of the remaining emulators can start.

3.5. Miscellaneous

a. Break-out sessions definition postponed (Lieve)

i. Spreadsheet for internal reporting of BOPTEST test cases

ii. Public reporting (limited information, end-user agreement)

iii. MPC competition: how to set up?

iv. How to deal with uncertainties: forecast of weather, loads, occupants?

b. Montreal meeting postponed to October (probably the week of October 12)

Next progress meeting: April 21