Skip to content

Meetingminutes Minutes30032016

Jump to bottom Edit New page
Bob Relyea edited this page Mar 5, 2025 · 3 revisions

March 30, 2016 Meeting Minutes

Meeting commenced 8:00PM GMT

  • Roll call (Valerie)

Proposed agenda

  • Review / approval of the agenda
  • Review of previous meeting minutes (March 16 , 2016)
  • V2.40
    • Errata Process update
  • Header files
    • Should we use github? or something to track edits? wiki?
  • V3.0
    • Dina: TLS 1.X text improvements
    • Dina: DSA text improvements, new mechanism
    • HMAC general mechanism. Signature length of 0. Issue closed
    • SHA3/Shake - Bob R
    • ChaCha20 - Chris Z
    • Poly1305 - Chris Z
    • ECDH Key Derivation - Christian
    • EncryptCancel, DigestCancel, etc - Valerie
    • C_GenerateRandom - needs owner
    • C_renameToken, ChangeLabel and/or ClearTOken - Oracle
    • CKA_UUID - Oracle
    • Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys - Graham S.
    • AEAD - Message Based Encryption Functions (BobR)
    • AES GCM proposal (Bob R)
    • Extending Function table (Bob R)
    • Forking (remove fork behaviour from standard, add fork_safe flag) - needs owner
    • C_LoginUser (Hai-May)
    • KMIP mappings - needs owner
  • NIST CMVP Feedback - Bob R.
  • New Business
  • Review Action Items
  • Adjourn
Motion to approve Agenda
  • Tim Moves, Chris seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Agenda approved.

Motion to approve meeting minutes

v2.40

Errata process update

  • Tim has produced a summary spreadsheet of the comments received for v2.40 which is with the co-chairs - Valerie will upload for broader review.
  • Valerie & Bob to review the list and send tro the wider TC for review.

Header Files

  • Tim working with Chet to see if github is a possibility
  • Lengthy discussion on identifiers and allocation of values with lots of input not captured in the minutes.
  • Agreement to take a subset group discussion off-line for those who indicated interest andf discuss firther with TC admin - Valerie, BobR, Tim, ChrisZ, Dina and will report back to the group the results of the discussion

Motion to use GitHub if possible

  • Motion to request that TC Admin provide a GitHub Repository for PKCS11's use .
  • Tim Moves, Jeff B seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Minutes approved.
  • Valerie to discuss with Chet as to which license we should use for GitHub (BSD, Apache 2.0, CC, Eclipse or use existing OASIS License).

v3.0

New doc version request

  • Do we need to request a new document version for v3.0 - Tim thinks yes.
  • Valerie to check with Chet.

Dina: TLS 1.X text improvements

  • Deferred while Dina brings document forward

Dina: DSA text improvements, new mechanism

  • Bob R. and Dina to discuss offline, then Dina will upload latest proposal.

HMAC general mechanism. Signature length of 0 is to be interpreted as an error.

  • Further discussion was had.
  • Dina to formalize her proposal for HMAC in the form of changes she wants in the specification (aka diffs), to upload it in the next couple of days.

Motion > 0 Signature length usage in HMAC General Ballot

  • Motion to Ballot a change to the specification to interpret a HMAC General Signature Length of 0 as an error on the proviso that Dina modifies the proposal to suit the resolution.
  • Chris Z Moves, Sue G seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions
  • Valerie to open a ballot the motion.

SHA3/Shake - Bob R

  • No comments

Motion > Include SHA3/Shake in v3.0

  • No more pending comments.
  • Take SHA3/Shake proposal to ballot - Tim Moves, Sue G seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions

ChaCha20 - Chris Z

  • Chris: one small typo corrected
  • Tim: Has a defined value for CKK been updated?
  • Chris: has been updated in the working draft
  • Tim: no it hasn't - it clashes with the ids from BobR for SHA3/Shake.

Poly1305 - Chris Z

Motion > Include ChaCHa20 & Poly1305 in v3.0

  • Motion to take ChaCha20 & Poly1305 proposal to ballot once Chris has updated the identifier to ensure no clashes.
  • Tim Moves, Sue G seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions

ECDH Key Derivation - Christian

  • Deferred

EncryptCancel, DigestCancel, etc - Valerie

  • Deferred

C_GenerateRandom - needs owner

  • Deferred

C_renameToken, ChangeLabel and/or ClearTOken - Oracle

  • Deferred

CKA_UUID - Oracle

  • Deferred

Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys - Graham S.

  • Deferred

AEAD - Message Based Encryption Functions (BobR)

  • Deferred

AES GCM proposal (Bob R)

  • Deferred

Extending Function table (Bob R)

  • Deferred

Forking (remove fork behaviour from standard, add fork_safe flag) - needs owner

  • BobR voluteered to take this.

C_LoginUser (Hai-May)

  • Deferred

KMIP mappings - needs owner

  • Tim voluteered to take this.

Further discussions on identifiers and version control

  • Unresolved after 20+ minutes of discussion - taken offline per earlier agreement.

NIST CMVP Feedback

  • Valerie described changes to the letter and indicated feedback had been incoroporated.

Motion > CMVP letter

  • Motion: take draft letter to CMVP to ballot for approval to send to NIST.
  • Tim Moves, Hai-May seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions

Next meeting date

  • 13th April, 2016

New Topic

  • Nothing.

Action Items

Call for late arrivals

  • Justin C - Cryptsoft.

Motion to Adjourn

  • Tim moves. Sue G seconds. No objections. No abstentions. Meeting adjourned.

Meeting Adjourned at 9:01PM GMT

Add a custom footer
Add a custom sidebar
Clone this wiki locally