Skip to content

Meetingminutes Minutes31082016

Bob Relyea edited this page Mar 4, 2025 · 1 revision

August 31, 2016 Meeting Minutes - DRAFT

Meeting commenced 8:00PM GMT

  • Roll call (Valerie) - quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

  • Roll call
  • Review / approval of the agenda
  • Review of previous meeting minutes (August 17,2016)
  • GitHub Repo update
  • V3.0
    • Usage Guide Editor
    • AES-XTS: Mark
    • TLS 1.X text improvements - Dina
    • DSA text improvements, new mechanism - Dina
    • SHA3/Shake - Bob R
    • ChaCha20 - Chris Z
    • Poly1305 - Chris Z
    • ECDH Key Derivation - Christian/Dieter
    • EncryptCancel, DigestCancel, etc - Valerie
    • C_GenerateRandom - Christian/Dieter
    • C_renameToken, ChangeLabel and/or ClearToken - Oracle
    • CKA_UUID - Oracle
    • Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys - Graham S.
    • AEAD - Message Based Encryption Functions - BobR
    • AES GCM proposal - Bob R
    • Extending Function table - Bob R
      • Forking (remove fork behaviour from standard, add fork_safe flag) - BobR
    • C_LoginUser - Hai-May
    • KMIP mappings - Tim
  • NIST CMVP Feedback - Tim
  • New Business
  • Next meeting date
  • Late Arrivals
  • Review Action Items
  • Adjourn
Motion to approve Agenda
  • Tim H Moves, Sue G seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Agenda approved.

Motion to approve meeting minutes

  • August 17, 2016August 17, 2016
  • Tim H Moves, Sue G seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Minutes approved.

GitHub Repo update

  • No further action has been taken

v3.0

Usage Guide Editor

  • Still only have one reluctant volunteer. Will leave the request open for a few weeks.

AES-XTS - Mark P

  • Mark P : It appears that NIST just want to use this for data encryption
  • Bob R: If someone needs this for wrap and unwrap, they can put forward a proposal
  • Bob R: We should probably leave the boxes unchecked
  • Tim: When the ballot closes, if it closes, Tim would be happy to make a motion that the wrap & unwrap flags be cleared - ie making a conditional motion.

Motion to clear the wrap & unwrap flags from the AES-XTS proposal if it passes

  • Tim moves, Mark P seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. motion made.

TLS 1.X text improvements - Dina

  • Bob R: Still working on feedback

DSA text improvements, new mechanism - Dina

  • No updated - deferred

SHA3/Shake - Bob R

  • Bob R: noted that he previously uploaded a draft 4 which was based on draft 1 rather than draft 3 but he corrected that with a draft 5.
  • Bob R: have uploaded draft 5 which as it turned out had a range of material changes. Bob feels that the scope of changes would warrant a new ballot.
  • Valerie requested the TC to review the draft 5 and see if a ballot needs to be run.

ChaCha20 - Chris Z

  • Ballot has passed - item will be dropped from agenda.

Poly1305 - Chris Z

  • Valerie: Ballot has passed - item will be dropped from agenda.

ECDH Key Derivation - Christian/Deiter

  • Valerie: Currently up for ballot requested folks to review

EncryptCancel, DigestCancel, etc - Valerie

  • No update - deferred

C_GenerateRandom - Deiter & Christian

  • No update - deferred

C_renameToken, ChangeLabel and/or ClearToken - Oracle

  • No update - deferred

CKA_UUID - Oracle

  • John Leser: Still working on a proposal

Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys - Graham S.

  • No update - deferred

AEAD - Message Based Encryption Functions (BobR)

  • Bob R: Received some comments from Tim H.
  • Tim H: Still needs to draft the proposal for Bob R

AES GCM proposal (Bob R)

  • As per AEAD

Extending Function table (Bob R)

  • Awaiting comments from Tim H

Forking (remove fork behavior from standard, add fork_safe flag) - Bob R

  • Awaiting comments from Tim H

C_LoginUser (Hai-May)

  • No update - deferred

KMIP mappings (Tim H)

  • No update - deferred

NIST CMVP Feedback

  • Still waiting for feedback from OASIS Legal.
  • CMVP are having a face to face meeting in October

New Business

  • None

Next meeting date

  • 14th September , 2016

New Topic

  • Valerie noted that she had made some changes to the PKCS11 wikipedia entry.

Action Items

Call for late arrivals

  • 1 members noted

Motion to Adjourn

  • Tim H Moves, Sue G seconds, No objections, no comments, no abstentions. Meeting adjourned.

Meeting Adjourned at 8:34PM GMT

Clone this wiki locally